Movie enthusiasts often ask, Is The Quiet Place Part 2 related to The Silence? It’s understandable. At first glance, both movies seem similar. Both feature sound-sensitive creatures and silent survival, leaving fans curious if they are connected.

But let me clear it up – Quiet Place Part 2 and The Silence are not related at all. While “A Quiet Place Part II” is a sequel to John Krasinski’s hit film, “The Silence” is based on a Tim Lebbon novel. They might share similar concepts, but their stories, creatures, and execution are very different.

In this blog, I’ll break down everything you need to know about these two films—their storylines, creatures, origins, and more. Stick around.

Category	A Quiet Place	The Silence
Story	Focused on one family’s survival.	Includes extra subplots like a cult.
Creatures	Alien monsters with sharp hearing.	Giant bats called Vesps.
Origin	Came from space on meteors.	Lived in caves on Earth.
Use of Sound	Makes every noise feel dangerous.	Doesn’t use sound as creatively.
Tone	Very tense and emotional.	Not as polished or scary.
Acting	Excellent performances.	Acting is okay, but less emotional.
Release	Came out in 2018.	Book in 2015, movie in 2019.

Is The Quiet Place Part 2 related to The Silence?

No, “A Quiet Place Part II” and “The Silence” are not related. While both movies show worlds where creatures attack anything that makes noise, they are separate stories. “A Quiet Place Part II” is a sequel to “A Quiet Place,” and “The Silence” is based on a novel by Tim Lebbon.

Now, the details.

Storyline: How “A Quiet Place Part II” and “The Silence” Are Different

A Quiet Place Part II movie continues the story of the Abbott family as they fight to survive in a dangerous, silent world. It begins with a flashback showing how the creatures first arrived, adding new details to the story. Then it moves forward, focusing on how the family adjusts after the events of the first movie.

The mother, Evelyn, and her children face new dangers, including other survivors who may or may not be friendly. The movie is about family, survival, and finding hope even in tough times. It balances intense action with emotional moments that make you care deeply about the characters.

On the other hand, “The Silence” is about the Andrews family, who face a similar situation but in a different way. The movie starts with scientists accidentally releasing Vesps, ancient creatures, from a cave. These creatures attack anything they hear. The Andrews family must leave their home and find a safe place to live.

Unlike “A Quiet Place Part II,” this movie includes other threats, like a strange cult that makes the family’s journey harder. The story isn’t as focused on one family’s emotions. It tries to show more about how society falls apart, but this can make it feel less personal.

Creatures: Alien Predators vs. Prehistoric Vesps

The creatures in A Quiet Place Part II movie are aliens that came to Earth on meteors. They are blind but have super hearing, so even the smallest sound attracts them. Their skin is tough, making them hard to kill, and their movements are quick and terrifying. These creatures feel very alien, and their behavior is unpredictable.

Because they came from space, their design is unique and scary. They are a big part of why the movie feels so tense. Every sound matters because the creatures are always listening and can attack instantly.

Get an idea by watching this A Quiet Place Part 2 trailer:

On the other hand, the creatures in “The Silence” are called Vesps. They are ancient animals that lived in caves for millions of years. When humans accidentally released them, they spread everywhere, attacking anything that made noise. Unlike the creatures in “A Quiet Place Part II,” Vesps look more like giant bats with wings.

Vesps are not as mysterious as the creatures in “A Quiet Place Part II” because they are from Earth. They usually attack in big groups, which can be frightening, but their design feels less creative. They are dangerous, but they don’t leave the same lasting impression as the aliens.

Origin: Extraterrestrial vs. Prehistoric

The creatures in A Quiet Place Part II movie came from space. They arrived on Earth when meteors crashed, bringing them here. This adds a sci-fi element to the story and makes the creatures feel otherworldly. Their arrival is shown briefly in the flashback at the start of the movie.

The idea that these creatures accidentally ended up on Earth adds mystery to their purpose. It also opens the door for more stories about where they came from and what else might exist in space.

Contrarily, in “The Silence,” the Vesps are not from space. They are very old creatures that have always lived on Earth but stayed hidden in underground caves. Humans accidentally released them when exploring these caves, causing them to spread and attack.

This origin is more grounded and tied to Earth’s history. It makes the story feel more like a cautionary tale about disturbing nature. While it is a believable explanation, it doesn’t feel as grand or intriguing as the idea of creatures from another planet.

Tone and Execution: Suspenseful Masterpiece vs. Mixed Results

A Quiet Place Part II movie is known for how it uses sound to create tension. Every quiet moment feels full of danger because the smallest noise can mean death. The director, John Krasinski, uses this to keep viewers on the edge of their seats. The movie is also visually stunning, with scenes that show both beauty and terror.

It doesn’t just focus on survival but also on emotions. The family’s love for each other drives the story, making the audience care deeply about what happens to them. It has been praised for its strong direction and acting, as well as its creative approach to horror.

While “The Silence” has a similar idea, it does not deliver the same level of quality. The movie has moments of suspense, but they are not as intense or well-executed. The story also tries to cover too many things, like the cult subplot, which can take away from the main threat of the Vesps.

Critics have said that “The Silence” feels like it copied some ideas from “A Quiet Place” but didn’t do as well. The acting and story are not as strong, and the movie feels less polished overall.

What Are the Similarities Between “A Quiet Place Part II” and “The Silence”?

Both A Quiet Place Part II and The Silence have characters trying to survive in a world taken over by sound-sensitive creatures. They are set in post-apocalyptic environments and focus on the dangers of making noise. The idea of silence being the key to survival is central to both stories.

Post-Apocalyptic Setting: A World in Ruins

In both movies, the world has completely changed. Society has fallen apart, and the characters live in fear of the creatures. “A Quiet Place Part II” shows empty towns, broken buildings, and abandoned places. The Abbotts move through this world, searching for safety while facing constant danger.

“The Silence” also shows a broken world, but it focuses more on the journey of the Andrews family. They travel through rural areas and encounter other survivors. While the settings feel similar, “A Quiet Place Part II” uses its environment to build tension more effectively.

Survival Focus: Staying Quiet to Stay Alive

Both stories center on characters who must avoid making noise to survive. In “A Quiet Place Part II,” the Abbotts use clever tools and strategies, like walking on sand paths or using sign language, to stay silent. Their survival feels very personal and emotional.

In “The Silence,” the Andrews family also tries to stay quiet, but the movie spends less time showing how they adapt. The focus is more on their journey and the obstacles they face along the way. This makes the survival aspect feel less detailed and impactful.

Creature Threat: The Danger of Noise

In both movies, the creatures are extremely sensitive to sound. In “A Quiet Place Part II,” this creates constant tension because even small noises can be deadly. The sound design in the movie is so well done that you feel the danger yourself.

“The Silence” uses the same idea, but the execution isn’t as strong. The Vesps are scary, but the movie doesn’t build suspense as effectively. Both movies explore the idea of sound as a threat, but “A Quiet Place Part II” does it with more skill and creativity.

Which Is Better: “The Silence” vs. “A Quiet Place”?

“A Quiet Place” is better than “The Silence” because it has a stronger story, better acting, and uses sound in creative ways to build suspense. While “The Silence” has an interesting concept, it doesn’t feel as well-made or emotional as “A Quiet Place.”

Storytelling: Why “A Quiet Place” Stands Out

“A Quiet Place” tells a very personal story about a family trying to survive in a world full of sound-hunting monsters. The movie focuses on their love for each other and how they work together to stay safe. This makes the story emotional and exciting.

In “The Silence,” the story is less focused. It follows the Andrews family, but there are many extra parts, like a strange cult. These distractions make it hard to connect deeply with the main characters. It feels like too much is happening at once.

“A Quiet Place” keeps things simple and focused on the family. This makes every scene more powerful. You care about the characters and feel scared for them. “The Silence” doesn’t have the same emotional connection, so it feels less intense.

Use of Sound: What Makes “A Quiet Place” Unique

One of the best things about “A Quiet Place” is how it uses sound. Silence is a big part of the movie, and every small noise feels dangerous. The sound design makes you feel like you’re part of the story. It keeps you on edge the whole time.

In “The Silence,” the idea of staying quiet is also important, but it’s not used as creatively. The movie doesn’t make you feel the danger of noise in the same way. The sound design is not as detailed or effective.

“A Quiet Place” turns sound into a tool for storytelling. It makes the quiet moments just as scary as the loud ones. This is something that “The Silence” doesn’t do as well, which is why it’s less memorable.

Acting and Characters: A Clear Winner

The actors in “A Quiet Place” are amazing. John Krasinski and Emily Blunt play the parents, and their performances are emotional and believable. The kids are also great, especially Millicent Simmonds, who plays the deaf daughter. The characters feel real, and you care about what happens to them.

In “The Silence,” the acting is decent, but it doesn’t stand out as much. The characters don’t feel as well-developed, so it’s harder to connect with them. You don’t feel the same level of tension or emotion.

The strong performances in “A Quiet Place” make the movie much more engaging. The characters feel like real people, and that makes their story much more impactful.

Speaking of real people, a lot of people still discuss how real characters in Lord of the Rings look. If you are fan of this trilogy, you will love reading How Does CGI in LOTR Still Look Good.

Which Came First: “The Silence” or “A Quiet Place”?

The book “The Silence” was published in 2015, three years before “A Quiet Place” came out in 2018. However, the movie version of “The Silence” was released in 2019, a year after “A Quiet Place” became popular.

“The Silence” started as a novel by Tim Lebbon, published in 2015. It tells the story of a family dealing with sound-sensitive creatures. The book came out well before anyone had heard of “A Quiet Place.”

“A Quiet Place” was released in 2018 and became a huge success. Its creative use of sound and focus on a family’s survival made it a hit with audiences and critics.

The movie adaptation of “The Silence” came out in 2019, a year after “A Quiet Place.” Because of this, many people compared the two movies and thought “The Silence” copied ideas from “A Quiet Place.”

Where to Watch “The Silence” and “A Quiet Place”

You can watch “A Quiet Place” and its sequel, “A Quiet Place Part II,” on streaming platforms like Paramount+ or Amazon Prime, depending on your region. Check these platforms for availability.

“The Silence” is available on Netflix, which is easy to find (if you have a subscription). Both movies can also be rented or bought on platforms like YouTube or Apple TV.

Conclusion

In summary:

• “A Quiet Place Part II” and “The Silence” may seem alike, but they are completely different.
• The Abbotts’ story in “A Quiet Place” is more emotional and suspenseful.
• “The Silence” includes a cult subplot that shifts focus.
• “A Quiet Place” wins with its strong acting, sound design, and storytelling.
• Both movies are worth a watch if you love suspense!

End your movie night with a thrilling story—whether it’s “A Quiet Place” or “The Silence.”